* League Tournament Champion
| Year | School |
|---|---|
| 2025 | 
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2025* | 
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2024 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2024* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2023 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2023* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2022 | 
Taylor |
| 2022* | 
Taylor |
| 2021 | 
Marian |
| 2021* | 
Marian |
| 2020 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2020* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2019 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2019 |
Marian |
| 2019* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2018 |
Marian |
| 2018* |
Marian |
| 2017 |
Marian |
| 2017* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2016 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2016* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2015 | 
Mt Vernon Nazarene |
| 2015 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2015* |
Mt Vernon Nazarene |
| 2014 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2014* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2013 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2013 | 
Bethel |
| 2013* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2012 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2012* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2011 |
Taylor |
| 2011* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2010 |
Taylor |
| 2010* |
Taylor |
| 2009 |
Taylor |
| 2009* |
Taylor |
| 2008 |
Taylor |
| 2008* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2007 |
Taylor |
| 2007 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2007* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2006 |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2006* |
Indiana Wesleyan |
| 2005 | 
Bethel |
| 2005* |
Indiana Wesleyan |